10:30am - 10:45amTopics: 03.06 Multiscale characterization of structure, flow and transport dynamics in fractured porous media and karst systemsUnresolved issues in fractured rock hydrogeology
Pierre Adler
Metis, Sorbonne Université, Paris, France
A brief historical review starts from the double porosity approach of Barenblatt in 1960; various versions of it are still used today despite the difficult evaluation of the exchange coefficient between the two media. Later, the homogenisation theory was applied, but it stopped before solving the macroscopic equations. A decisive step was achieved in 1980 by viewing a fracture network as a set of disks randomly distributed in space. This was the starting point of our own works with additional ideas such as the crucial role of the dimensionless density for convex fractures and the use of systematic numerical experiments in order to rationalize the results.
Today, with the powerful computers at our disposal, very complex configurations can be addressed, but the theoretical and methodological gains are limited.
Therefore, the basic issues have not changed for real networks. They can be summarized and illustrated by our simple approach. First, what are the most salient features of the measurements made on oucrops and wells? Some of them provided a basis to the theoretical predictions of quantities such as percolation and macroscopic permeability, but alternative approaches could certainly be developed. Second, how can we reconstruct, i.e., generate realistic networks based on these measurements? Statistical techniques have been extensively used, but more advanced techniques such as AI should be envisioned. Third, experimental results are usually scarce and often not easily compared with numerical predictions.
Despite and/or because all these difficulties, this field is expected to remain very active in the future.
10:45am - 11:00amTopics: 03.06 Multiscale characterization of structure, flow and transport dynamics in fractured porous media and karst systemsWetting front dynamics in partially saturated fractured-porous media: Limitations and improvements of classical analytical modeling approaches
Florian Rüdiger1, Marco Dentz2, Jannes Kordilla1,2
1Geoscience Center, Applied Geology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany; 2Institute of Environmental Assessment and Water Research (IDAEA), Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), Barcelona, Spain
A vast amount of aquifer systems resides in consolidated fractured media formations, which provide pathways for preferential flow, while the porous rock matrix acts as storage that delays fluid propagation via matrix imbibition. Due to the rise of extreme climatic conditions, which favour high-intensity but low-frequency precipitation events in (semi-)arid regions, it is crucial to refine the understanding of infiltration processes through the deep vadose zone in such systems. In this work we study dual‐porosity flow mechanisms using novel laboratory setups, which allow to investigate fracture infiltration under partially saturated conditions. The experimental data is interpreted using established analytical models, which account for the impact of fracture‐matrix interactions on fluid propagation in the fracture. We find that matrix imbibition affects the observed discontinuous, partially saturated fracture flow to behave, on average, like plug flow. Consequently, and within the range of applied flow rates above a critical threshold, the original model’s plug flow assumption is not a relevant precondition for its applicability. Fluid propagation in the fracture exhibits three characteristic scaling regimes (FP1‐3) corresponding to the matrix imbibition state. We demonstrate that only two scaling regimes are established for flow rates below a critical threshold, hence required to recover bulk infiltration for the chosen geometry. Furthermore, wetting fronts switch from fracture- to matrix‐dominated at moderate to high flow rates, indicating a flow‐rate‐dependent limitation of fracture-dominated infiltration depth. While the scaling regimes agree with experiments for applied flow rates above the critical threshold, the model underestimates the initial penetration depth below.
11:15am - 11:30amTopics: 03.06 Multiscale characterization of structure, flow and transport dynamics in fractured porous media and karst systemsCoupled Thermal and Hydraulic Effects in Low-Permeability Barriers: Insights from the HotBENT In-Situ Experiment
Alexandru Tatomir1, Tymofiy Gerasimov2, Eric Simo2, Victoria Burlaka2, Mirko Polster2, Astrid Göbel1, Axel Liebscher1
1BGE mbH, Federal Company for Radioactive Waste Disposal, Germany; 2BGE TECHNOLOGY GmbH, Germany
The HotBENT experiment at the Grimsel Test Site investigates the coupled thermal and hydraulic behaviour of a bentonite barrier subjected to high temperatures. The setup includes four electric heaters embedded in a bentonite buffer, with temperatures reaching up to 200 °C. Four “enhanced geosphere pressurization boreholes” using natural Grimsel groundwater support and enhance hydration of the bentonite buffer via surrounding fractured granite. This configuration induces complex interactions between drying, vapour transport, and re-saturation processes.
We present results from 3D fully coupled thermo-hydraulic simulations conducted using OpenGeoSys. The model incorporates temperature-dependent transport properties, bentonite-specific retention behaviour, and hydration from the surrounding granite. Although fractures are not explicitly represented, the surrounding rock acts as a boundary condition influencing water inflow into the bentonite.
Experimental data are used for calibration and validation. The study highlights how temperature gradients affect saturation, vapour movement, and pressure development in low-permeability media. We also discuss numerical challenges related to material nonlinearity and boundary implementation.
These results enhance our understanding of thermo-hydraulic behaviour in engineered barriers and their interaction with fractured host rocks — even when treated as continuous domains — supporting predictive modelling efforts in subsurface systems.
11:30am - 11:45amTopics: 03.06 Multiscale characterization of structure, flow and transport dynamics in fractured porous media and karst systemsEffects of Thermoelasticity induced Aperture Variation on Performances of Enhanced Geothermal System
Dejian ZHOU1,2, Alexandru Tatomir2, Quan Liu2, Ke Li3, Huhao Gao1,2, Martin Sauter1,2
1LIAG, Germany; 2University of Göttingen; 3TU Clausthal
Geothermal energy, as one of the renewable energy types, has great potential to balance the variable energy supply from photovoltaic and wind energy types. This, however, requires the development of an Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS). Injecting cold water into deep geo-reservoirs induces thermoelastic deformation and changes the fracture apertures, which may significantly affect the EGS lifetime and energy performance. In this case, this study develops a fully coupled thermal-hydraulic-mechanical model to investigate the impacts of temperature, pressure, and aperture heterogeneity on the alterations of fracture aperture. Then, considering the reservoir lifespan, the research takes a further step into the influence of heterogeneous aperture variation on EGS production temperature and long-term energy performance. Results show that aperture significantly varies once a temperature breakthrough occurs in the production well for both homogeneous and heterogeneous aperture fields. The thermoelasticity-induced aperture variations enhance water flow rate, leading to a considerable increase in reservoir heat production rate, but a shorter EGS lifespan. Furthermore, temperature variation shows a more substantial influence on aperture alteration compared to pressure change. Additionally, a sensitivity analysis indicates that the 30-year total energy output is proportional to the injection/production pressures and injection temperatures. However, the fracture with either excessively large or small initial apertures leads to worse EGS energy performance.
11:45am - 12:00pmTopics: 03.06 Multiscale characterization of structure, flow and transport dynamics in fractured porous media and karst systemsEstimation of recovery efficiency in high-temperature aquifer thermal energy storage
Huhao Gao1,2, D. Zhou1,2, A. Tatomir2, K. Li3, L. Ganzer3, P. Jaeger3, G. Brenner4, M. Sauter1,2
1Leibniz Institute for Applied Geophysics, 30655 Hannover, Germany.; 2Department of Applied Geology, University of Göttingen, 37073, Göttingen, Germany.; 3Institute of Subsurface Energy Systems, Clausthal University of Technology, 38678 Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Germany; 4Institute of Applied Mechanics, Clausthal University of Technology, 38678 Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Germany
High-temperature aquifer thermal energy storage (HT-ATES), with its high storage capacity and energy efficiency and its compatibilities with renewable energy sources, has generated widespread interest. One main criterion for a feasible HT-ATES is the thermal recovery efficiency, i.e., how much of the invested heat can be recovered. The heat lost during the HT-ATES is mainly due to the heat conduction and the density-driven buoyancy flow, which are more significant with HT-ATES compared to the conventional low-temperature ATES. Thus, understanding the fluid displacement and thermal transport processes during HT-ATES is essential for assessing the performance of HT-ATES. A group of key dimensionless parameters regarding the thermal recovery efficiency for HT-ATES are identified in this study. The numerical model is set for a typical HT-ATES based on the geological in the Burgwedel region and the designed operational parameters. Over one thousand cases are simulated for a sweep of the key parameters for multiple cycles and storage volumes, and the resulting recovery efficiency for each case is obtained. The hot water injection and displacement processes and the correlation between the recovery efficiency and the key parameters are investigated. The correlation functions are built to estimate the thermal recovery efficiency, which can be used for a quick assessment of potential HT-ATES sites when the properties of the aquifer are known.
|