Conference Agenda
Overview and details of the sessions of this conference. Please select a date or location to show only sessions at that day or location. Please select a single session for detailed view (with abstracts and downloads if available).
|
Daily Overview |
| Session | |
|
S43: Epistemology 4 Location: 23.21 U1.76 Session Chair: Sebastian Schmidt Session Chair: Lukas Lewerentz | |
| Presentation 3 | |
3:45pm - 4:30pm
Standpoint Epistemologies, Epistemic Cooperation, and Deference unaffiliated, Germany In my talk, I will discuss the recently presented claim by Tilton and Toole that dominant knowers can and should hold marginalized standpoints. While their arguments are mostly convincing, I will show that some problems arise with this view that have not been discussed in standpoint epistemology. For instance, standpoint epistemologists have conceived the method for achieving a standpoint (consciousness-raising) as exclusionary to dominant knowers. I will argue that we should understand consciousness-raising as a process of epistemic cooperation. Then, I will provide some epistemic norms for such cooperation between marginalized and dominant knowers for the latter to achieve standpoints. To do so, I will also discuss a joint paper by Tilton and Toole in which they respond to Taiwo’s critique on deference. Contrary to them, I will argue that for dominant knowers to achieve standpoints, they must defer to epistemically superior marginalized knowers to access relevant evidence and epistemic virtues and behaviours. I will conclude with some words of caution for dominant knowers on how not to dominate marginalized knowers but help to further (epistemic) justice for them. | |

