The Role of Hope and Attitudes Toward Time Across Developmental Periods
Chair(s): Frank C Worrell (University of California, Berkeley, United States of America)
The importance of time constructs in psychological functioning has been acknowledged since the 1930s. The contributions of constructs such as self-esteem (present-oriented) and optimism (future-oriented) to wellbeing are well documented in the literature, as are the contributions of variables such as life satisfaction (present-oriented) and self-efficacy, which is present/future-oriented. In the past 25 years, there has been an increased focus on assessing individuals’ orientations to all three time periods—that is, the past, present, and future—due in part to the introduction of several measures that assess these. In this symposium, we provide analyses on hope, a present/future-oriented construct, as well as time attitudes which focus on all three time periods.
Recent research using person-centered approaches such as cluster analysis and latent profile analysis has demonstrated that adolescents and adults have profiles that are associated with psychological and behavioral outcomes. However, there are very few studies that have looked at these temporal profiles across developmental periods. In this symposium, we examine time construct profiles across developmental periods in data from three different countries. In the first presentation, hope profiles were examined in relation to academic motivation in the same sample of U.S. adolescents across two time periods. Presentation 2 will report on a cross-sectional analysis of time attitude profiles and ethnic identity in academically talented early- and middle- adolescents in the US. Presentation 3 will report on time attitude profile membership patterns in adolescent and adult samples from Iran, as well as the association of the profiles to life satisfaction in both samples. Finally, the fourth presentation will be on a longitudinal investigation of time attitude profiles in adolescents from Scotland (4 waves) and Northern Ireland (6 waves), with a focus on how staying in or changing a time attitude profile over time affects self-efficacy, substance use, and mental health.
Presentations of the Symposium
Profiles of Academic Hope in American Adolescents
Dante D. Dixson Michigan State University
Hope, the perceived ability to execute envisioned paths to future goals, has been found to predict a host of academic outcomes (e.g., academic achievement, academic engagement, curiosity; Chen, 2020; Dixson, 2019). In addition, intervention studies have demonstrated that hope can be improved in as little as 90 minutes (Feldman & Dreher, 2012). However, most hope research is centered around examining hope as a global construct as opposed to focusing on its subscales, which would provide a more nuanced understanding of hopeful thinking (Dixson et al., 2017). In addition, previous examinations of profiles of hope have been cross-sectional and indicated uncertainty around the number of hope clusters that exist (i.e., three or four; Dixson, 2019; Dixson et al., 2017). In the current study, I examined the number of hope clusters in a sample as well as to what degree different profiles of hope relate to different academic-oriented psychosocial profiles.
The current sample consisted of a group of diverse high school students (Mage = 15.56 years, 44.8% White, 8.3% Asian American, 5.6% African American, 9.8% Hispanic, and 31.6% Multi-race/Other) from a Midwestern state. A K-means cluster analysis yielded four interpretable clusters of hope that were consistent with previous research (i.e., high hopers, high agency thinkers, high pathway thinkers, and low hopers; Dixson et al., 2017) and theory (Snyder, 2002). In addition, the different hope clusters reported different (i.e., 78% of the variable comparisons across clusters had at least a medium effect size) academic-oriented psychosocial profiles (i.e., made up of academic self-concept, goal-valuation, academic motivation, attitude toward mathematics, and academic self-efficacy), both cross-sectionally and across time. In general, across both time periods, the high hopers reported the most success-oriented profile, followed by the high agency and pathways thinkers, and then the low hopers. The high agency and pathway thinkers reported similar academic profiles.
Differences in Ethnic Identity and Time Attitude Profiles in Early and Middle Adolescents in the United States
Frank C Worrell1, James R. Andretta2 1University of California, Berkeley, 2Bridgetown Psychological
Ethnic identity is a frequently studied construct in ethnic minorities and is often conceptualized in terms of exploration (i.e., seeking information about one’s group) and commitment (i.e., a feeling of belonging to one’s ethnic group). Adolescence is a developmental period in which there is increased exploration of identity. Time attitudes are individuals’ positive or negative feelings toward the past, present, and future. Positive-oriented profiles have been associated with adaptive outcomes and negative-oriented profiles have been associated with maladaptive outcomes. In this study, we examined the association between time attitude profiles and ethnic identity exploration and commitment in a sample of high achieving students in early (n = 447, M age = 13.1 years) and middle-adolescence (n = 491, M age = 15.3 years).
Cluster analyses yielded four groups labeled Negatives (n = 84), Pessimists (n = 240), Ambivalents (n = 321), and Positives (n = 293). We also divided adolescents into four ethnocultural groups: marginalized ethnic minorities (i.e., African American, Hispanic; n = 146), model minorities (e.g., Chinese American, Japanese American; n = 620), majority group members (i.e., European Americans; n = 88), and an Other group consisting of individuals who were multi-ethnic (n = 208). White adolescents reported lower ethnic identity exploration, commitment, and total scores than their peers (ds ≥ .57). Early and middle adolescents did not differ significantly or meaningfully on the identity variables and were combined for further analyses. ANOVAs indicated that Negatives had the lowest ethnic identity scores in all four ethnocultural groups, Positives had the highest ethnic identity in three groups (Other was the exception), and Pessimists and Ambivalents were generally between the Negatives and Positives. These findings suggest that time attitude profiles are strongly associated ethnic identity achievement, with positive attitudes toward time potentially facilitating ethnic identity exploration and commitment, and ultimately, achievement.
Time Attitude Profiles in High School and University Students in Iran
James R. Andretta1, Khosro Rashid2, Frank C Worrell3 1Bridgetown Psychological, 2Bu-Ali Sina University, 3University of California, Berkeley
The Adolescent and Adult Time Inventory–Time Attitudes Scale (AATI-TA) has six subscales—Past Positive, Past Negative, Present Positive, Present Negative, Future Positive, and Future Negative—and is an index of emotional and evaluative feelings toward the time periods. Research indicates that individuals have time attitude profiles which can be positive or negative. As Iran has been under economic sanctions for a long time and these sanctions have had a negative impact on its population, we had questions about time attitudes there. First, would we find both positive- and negative-oriented profiles? Second, would the association between profile membership and life satisfaction be similar to profiles found in research in other countries? Third, how would percentages of individuals within time profiles differ across adolescents and young adults? Fourth, would profiles in Iran be similar to profiles found in other countries?
Our sample consisted of 387 adolescents (Mean-age = 17.11, SD = 1.75) and 378 young adults (Mean-age = 22.96, SD = 4.38) in Iran. Latent profile analyses (LPA) yielded five profiles (Positives, Optimists, Present Positives, Moderate Negatives, Extreme Negatives) in the university sample and four (Positives, Ambivalents, Moderate Negatives, Extreme Negatives) in the high school sample, with three profiles in common (Positives, Moderate Negatives, and. Extreme Negatives). Individuals in the present-oriented profiles reported considerably higher life satisfaction (Cohen’s d ≥ .40) than the negative-oriented profiles. Thirty percent of adolescents were Positives compared to 20% of young adults, and 25% of young adults were Moderate Negatives compared to 20% of adolescents. About 10% of both groups were Extreme Negatives, 35% of adolescents were Ambivalents, and 33% of young adults were Present Positives. At 35% and 40%, respectively, a greater percentage of Iranian adolescents and adults were in one of the negative profiles than in samples in Germany, New Zealand, and the US.
Change and Stability in Time Attitude Profiles Across Adolescence in the United Kingdom: Associations with Mental Well-Being and Physical Health
Michael T. McKay1, Noah Padgett2, James R. Andretta3 1Ulster University, 2Harvard University, 3Bridgetown Psychological
Research has demonstrated statistically significant and substantive relationships between time constructs and adaptive functioning, addictive behaviors, and mental health. However, most of these studies have been cross-sectional. Building on a small number of prospective studies, we will utilize data from a longitudinal cohort of adolescents in the United Kingdom to employ a latent profile mover/stayer analytical approach to investigate four inter-related questions:
- To what extent are time attitudes stable over the course of high school, and to what degree is the stability/instability related to socio-demographic variables?
- To what extent does time attitude profile membership relate to or predict changes in psychological constructs, including sensation seeking, and social, emotional, and academic self-efficacy?
- To what extent does time attitudes profile membership predict the initiation and maintenance of addictive behaviors, including smoking, alcohol use, and cannabis use?
- To what extent does time attitudes profile membership predict changes in other health-related outcomes including mental well-being, physical symptomatology, and psychological symptomatology?
The sample (» 2,500) were part of a larger cohort (» 11,000) participating in a school-based cluster randomized controlled trial of a school-based health intervention in schools in both Scotland and Northern Ireland. Data on time attitudes were gathered opportunistically as part of the larger data collection. The analyses for this presentation will cover a four-year developmental period (T1 to T4; Mage = 12.5, to 15.3 years), with distal health outcomes assessed also at +6 years from baseline. Based on analyses focused only on T1 and T2 (McKay et al., 2018; Wells et al., 2018), we hypothesized that (a) 33% to 40% of adolescents will have the same time attitude profiles over time, (b) that profile stability vs. moving to a different profile will predict different outcomes, with movement toward positive profiles resulting in more adaptive outcomes and vice versa.
|